FACT: One-third of all fatal and serious traffic crashes are due at least in part to poor road conditions.

Are we a donor state?

Posted on March 4th, by Michigan Transportation Team in Latest News, News and Blog. Comments Off on Are we a donor state?

This question comes up many times during discussions about increasing funding for infrastructure:  Is Michigan a donor state to the federal government?  Do we give more to the government in fuel taxes than we receive?  According to an article published today by Mlive, the answer is complex.

As Michigan lawmakers consider ways to raise more than $1 billion a year in new transportation funding, some critics questioning the need for additional revenue have referred to Michigan as a “donor state.”

If only the federal government would give us back what we pay in, they say, Michigan residents would not face the prospect of increased state fuel taxes or vehicle registration fees to fund road repairs.

That argument is something of a non-starter, however, as the federal government is now sending more money to Michigan than it collects here at the pump…

However, there are different ways to look at the issue.

As the House Fiscal Agency also pointed out, rate of returns often are calculated by comparing each state’s share of federal funding to their share of contributions to the Highway Trust Fund. In that respect, Michigan could be considered a transportation donor state because it contributed a larger percentage than it got back, realizing a relative return rate of only 90 percent.


The bottom line is this: Michigan needs more state funding for infrastructure NOW!

Contact your legislators today and remind them that it will save money and lives in the future if they find a way to increase funding for our roads and bridges today.


Latest News and Blog Posts

Come back frequently for the latest news on Michigan's roads crisis, along with blog posts from members of our coalition and others who agree: just fix the roads now!

Deal: $1.2B Road Funding Plan Heads to Michigan Gov. Snyder’s Desk After Legislative Approval
November 4, 2015
Michigan's Republican-led Legislature has sent a long-term road funding plan to Governor Snyder's desk.
House Passes Sweeping Roads Plan Raising Gax Tax, Fees
October 22, 2015
The House passed a sweeping roads plan that raises the gax tax and registration fees.
Mlive: Roads Deal Close . . .
October 6, 2015
Michigan House Speaker says a plan for road funding is on pace to hit the floor this month.
A Third Of States Boost Funding For Road Repairs
August 18, 2015
States are doing what they can to raise road funding.
Senate plan for roads includes 15-cent boost in gas tax
June 30, 2015
The Senate plan for roads will phase in an increased gas tax over three years.
From the News: Recent Progress on Road Funding
June 16, 2015
The House recently passed legislation to help fund roads, and the Senate has pledged to work during the summer to come up with a...
House Speaker Proposes New Road Plan
May 14, 2015
A new state road funding plan has been proposed by the Speaker of the House.